Part 3 — Structure the account around margin, not vibes
Consolidate for learning volume, segment only where economics genuinely differ, and isolate brand from day one.
Account structure has one job in the Smart Bidding era: give the algorithm clean, sufficient signal while keeping control where your economics demand it. The old instinct — mirror the site taxonomy, one campaign per category, dozens of micro-segmented ad groups — starves every campaign below learning volume and hands you back noise. The modern instinct — one campaign, everything in it — hands Google decisions it will resolve in its own favor. The right structure sits between, and your part 1 margin bands define exactly where.
The consolidation rule
Automated bidding needs roughly 30+ conversions per month per campaign to clear the learning phase; below that, targets are guesses and performance whipsaws. So consolidate until each campaign clears the floor — then and only then consider splitting. The legitimate reasons to split are economic, not organizational: different margin bands (which need different ROAS targets), different strategic roles (acquisition vs. clearance), or genuinely different demand pools. "The site has a menu item for it" is not a reason. The fuller argument, including how account standards encode this, is worth the detour.
Brand and non-brand: never blended
Brand search converts at multiples of non-brand because the customer had already decided; blending them lets brand’s easy wins subsidize non-brand’s real costs and flatters every average the account reports. Isolate brand into its own campaign with its own budget and modest targets, and read growth from non-brand — the traffic that represents customers you did not already have. We covered the measurement distortion in brand vs non-brand; structurally, the separation is non-negotiable and costs nothing to do on day one.
A reference shape for a typical store
- Brand Search — exact and phrase brand terms, capped budget, high impression-share target.
- Non-brand Search — the head terms your category genuinely wins, consolidated until conversion volume justifies splits.
- Shopping or PMax segmented by margin band via custom labels — each band with a ROAS target derived from ITS breakeven, not the account average (part 4 and 5 cover the Shopping/PMax split itself).
- Remarketing/retention kept deliberately small and honestly measured — it harvests decided demand and should never be allowed to inflate blended results.
Structure test: for every campaign, you should be able to state in one sentence why it exists as a separate spend decision — and the sentence must contain a number (margin, target, budget cap). "To keep things organized" fails the test.